Comerford v. Pryor Foundry5/28/1999
This appeal presents two questions: (1) whether the Special Indemnity Fund tax imposed by 85 O.S.Supp.1993 § 173(C) on awards for permanent total disability (PTD) is to be deducted from PTD awards revived pursuant to 85 O.S.Supp.1994 § 48(2), and, if so, (2) whether that tax can be increased from 3%, the rate ordered by the original PTD award, to 5%, the rate currently provided by § 173(C).
Petitioner Lois Comerford (Spouse) is the dependent widow of Claimant Gerald Comerford, deceased. On November 14, 1994, the Workers' Compensation Court entered an order finding that Claimant had sustained a work-related back injury on February 9, 1990, awarded him PTD benefits, setting those benefits at $246 per week. In addition, the Court ordered that Claimant's attorney be paid $19,050 in a lump sum and set the recoupment of the fee at 10% of the weekly payments. By order nunc pro tunc filed November 29, 1994, the Court corrected its previous order by adding two paragraphs including, inter alia, the payment of the Special Indemnity Fund tax at the rate of 3% by Claimant and 3% by Pryor Foundry. After all deductions from the $246 weekly benefits, Claimant was paid a net of $214.02 per week.
Claimant died from causes unrelated to his workers' compensation claim on May 3, 1997, but Pryor Foundry continued to pay his weekly checks until June 1, 1997. Spouse moved to revive Claimant's permanent total disability award pursuant to § 48(2). The Workers' Compensation Court entered an order filed August 7, 1998, that (1) sustained Spouse's motion, (2) set the benefit at $50 per week, the maximum amount allowed by § 48(2), (3) commuted the amount of weekly benefits due from June 1, 1997 through August 7, 1998, to a lump sum of $3,075, (4) increased the Special Indemnity Fund tax payable by both parties from 3% to 5 %, and (5) made findings, in paragraphs 2 and 7, respectively, that Claimant had died on May 7, 1997, and that Pryor Foundry was entitled "to a credit for payment of benefits from May 7, 1997 to June 1, 1997, a period of 3 weeks and 4 days, in the amount of $902.00 to be deducted from the accrued portion herein." By order nunc pro tunc filed August 24, 1998, the Court vacated paragraphs 2 and 7, entering in lieu thereof two paragraphs correcting Claimant's date of death to May 3, 1997, and Pryor Foundry's credit for payment of benefits "from May 3, 1997 to June 1, 1997, a period of 4 weeks and 1 day, in the amount of $1,025.00 to be deducted from the accrued portion herein." The court further ordered that all other provisions of its August 7, 1998 order remain in full force and effect.
In this review proceeding, Spouse argues that the Special Indemnity Fund tax should not be deducted from her benefits because § 173(C) applies to awards for permanent partial disability (PPD) and PTD only and § 48(2) does not provide for payment of that tax. However, her interpretation of these statutes fails to consider the rules of statutory construction that statutes should be construed together, Chamberlain v. American Airlines, 1987 OK 62, 740 P.2d 717, and that our primary goal is to ascertain legislative intent, not from individual provisions, but from the whole act in light of the general purpose and objective, City of Bethany v. Public Employees Relations Board of the State of Oklahoma, 1995 OK 99, 904 P.2d 604. If the language is plain and clearly expresses legislative will, such language will be followed without further inquiry. State ex rel. Department of Public Safety v. 1985 GMC Pickup, 1995 OK 75, 898 P.2d 1280.
Since 1978, the Legislature has made no changes to § 48(2), which provides:
"If claimant has been adJudged a permanent totally disabled pers
Page 1 2 3 Oklahoma Personal Injury Attorneys
Personal Injury Lawyers
|