 |
 |
to fill out a simple form to connect to Personal Injury Lawyers in your area.
|
|
|
|
|
Smith v. Kulig5/17/2005
AFFIRMED.
[ ] Rhonda Smith, as the special administrator for the estate of her deceased husband, Kelly Smith, appealed from a dismissal of her wrongful death action against Tony Kulig. We hold the trial court's conclusion that Kelly Smith was a trespasser on Kulig's property and his death was not caused by willful or wanton conduct by Kulig is supported by the evidence, and we affirm.
I.
[ ] Kulig owns a four-story building in Minot with two commercial businesses on the main floor and four apartments leased on the second floor. The third and fourth floors are vacant. The building entrance is on the west side facing Main Street, and there is a separate door for residential tenants to enter the building. The door is kept locked at all times so that only tenants and invited guests may enter the premises, and all tenants have a key to the front door. Attached to the back east side of the building is a fire escape. Access to the fire escape can be gained through a second floor door onto a landing. At the bottom of the fire escape, a ladder is located approximately seven feet above the ground and, therefore, access from the ground is limited. Kulig instructed tenants of the building, including Michael Spotted Wolf, who rented one of the second floor apartments, they were not to use the fire escape for entering or exiting the building. It was to be used only in the case of an emergency. Kulig posted "no trespassing" signs on both sides of the second floor door leading to the fire escape landing, on the landing itself, and on the ladder between the landing and the ground.
[ ] On July 22, 2000, Kelly Smith and Sonny Smith were visiting Spotted Wolf in his apartment in Kulig's building and were drinking most of the afternoon in the apartment. Sometime around 10:00 p.m., Kelly Smith visited a relative at another location in Minot. While Kelly Smith was visiting the relative, Sonny Smith phoned and invited Kelly Smith to come back to Spotted Wolf's apartment. Kelly Smith was later seen by a witness at a local bar around its closing time of 1:00 a.m. on the morning of July 23, 2000. No one saw Smith again until approximately 2:00 a.m., when his body was discovered lying in the alley beneath the fire escape on the east side of Kulig's apartment building.
[ ] Rhonda Smith filed a wrongful death action against Kulig, alleging Kelly Smith was killed while walking on the fire escape when attachment bolts securing the fire escape "came out of the wall." She alleged the death was the result of Kulig's negligent failure to provide a safe environment and to keep the fire escape serviced in a safe manner. The case was tried to the court. Dr. John Smith testified the cause of Kelly Smith's death was "a fall from a balcony of a fire escape." Clint Wolf, an investigator with the Minot Police Department, testified that attachment bolts were missing from the fire escape, which allowed it to swing away from the wall, presumably causing Smith to fall to the street. The trial court found that Smith, while using the fire escape to enter or exit the building, was a trespasser to whom Kulig did not owe a duty other than to refrain from harming him in a willful or wanton manner. The court determined Kulig did not breach his duty to Smith, and the court dismissed the action with prejudice on its merits.
II.
[ ] Rhonda Smith argues the trial court erred in finding Kelly Smith was a trespasser when he presumably fell off the fire escape of Kulig's building. Landowners owe a general duty to lawful entrants to maintain their property in a reasonably safe condition under the circumstances. Sternberger v. City of Williston, 556 N.W.2d 288, 290 (N.D. 1996). However,
Page 1 2 3 4 North Dakota Personal Injury Attorneys
Personal Injury Lawyers
|
| |
to fill out a simple form to connect to Personal Injury Lawyers in your area.
|
|